Finalize my selection 0

You have not selected a product

Trucker getting into blue cab in background with tire in foreground

Michelin X Line Energy Z+ tire in foreground

How Fuel Efficient Tires Impact Fleet Costs

Published on April 25, 2024 - 5 minute read

How Fuel Efficient Tires Impacts Fleet Costs

UPDATED November 2026

Fuel-efficient tires can help fleets reduce operating costs by lowering fuel consumption, but the purchase price of a tire is only part of the equation. To understand the true financial impact of tire selection, fleet managers need to consider fuel efficiency, tire life, maintenance and downtime.

That's where total cost of ownership (TCO) comes in. Rather than evaluating tires based solely on purchase price or cost per mile, TCO considers how tire performance affects overall fleet operating expenses. 

In this article, we'll explore how fuel-efficient tires impact fleet costs, why TCO matters and how a real-world fleet calculation demonstrates the potential savings of low-rolling-resistance tires.

 

Although CPM works pretty well, it has a tendency to look at things in silos, and it could lead to less-than-optimal practices.

Jim Garrett – Product Category Manager, Michelin North America

Why Cost Per Mile Doesn't Tell the Whole Story

Cost per mile (CPM) is a common way to evaluate tire costs. It's calculated by dividing the tire purchase price by the miles driven before replacement. While CPM is useful, it doesn't account for all the operating expenses that tire selection can influence.

Consider purchasing a truck. Looking only at the purchase price and expected mileage doesn't tell you which vehicle offers the best long-term value. Fuel efficiency, preventive maintenance, replacement parts and repair costs all contribute to the total cost of operating that truck. A less expensive vehicle upfront could ultimately cost more over its lifetime.

The same principle applies to tires. A tire with a lower purchase price isn't necessarily the most cost-effective option when you consider fuel consumption, tire life, maintenance and potential downtime from tire-related breakdowns.

By evaluating total cost of ownership (TCO) instead of CPM alone, fleet managers can better understand how tire selection affects overall operating costs and make more informed purchasing decisions.

For a broader look at managing fleet expenses, explore our guide on how to reduce fleet costs through TCO analysis

 

The Fuel-to-Tire Cost Ratio: Why It Matters

Fuel consumption is one of the most important factors to consider when evaluating the total cost of ownership of commercial truck tires. While purchase price and tire life affect overall costs, rolling resistance can also influence how much fuel a fleet consumes over time.

Tire TCO = Tire Purchase Costs + Fuel Costs + Tire Maintenance Costs

This calculation can be evaluated annually or on a cost-per-mile basis to help fleet managers compare tire options beyond their initial purchase price.

For perspective, fuel expenses over the life of a set of long-haul tires can be approximately 10 to 15 times the cost of the tires themselves, depending on fuel prices. According to Datatruck, fuel accounts for approximately 20% to 30% of a trucking company's total operating costs, making fuel efficiency an important consideration in fleet cost management.

Because tire rolling resistance accounts for approximately one-third of the energy required to move a vehicle,² choosing tires designed with lower rolling resistance can help reduce fuel consumption and improve overall fleet operating efficiency.

Michelin offers fuel-efficient commercial truck tires designed for different applications, including the Michelin X® Line Energy range for long-haul operations and Michelin Multi Energy tires for regional applications.

For additional information, explore fuel-efficient tires for long-haul trucking or learn more about ways to reduce commercial truck fuel consumption.
 

Infographic showing four components of commercial truck tire total cost of ownership: tire purchase costs, fuel costs influenced by rolling resistance, maintenance expenses and tire-related downtime costs.

What Goes Into Tire Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)?

Understanding tire total cost of ownership means looking beyond purchase price to consider fuel, maintenance and downtime expenses.


Real-World Example: Calculating TCO for Low-Rolling-Resistance Tires

How much can fuel-efficient tires actually save a fleet? Using the Michelin Fuel Savings Calculator, we can compare two tire configurations to see how rolling resistance, tire purchase price and tread life affect total cost of ownership.

The Fleet Scenario

Consider a fleet of 100 6x4 trucks, each traveling 100,000 miles annually, averaging 7 miles per gallon (mpg), with diesel fuel costing $4 per gallon.

Based on these assumptions, the fleet's estimated annual operating costs include:

  • •  Fuel costs: $57,143 per truck, or approximately $5.71 million across the fleet.

  • •  Tire costs: $3,644 per truck, or approximately $364,444 across the fleet.

In this scenario, annual fuel expenses are more than 15 times the cost of tires, demonstrating why fuel efficiency is an important consideration when evaluating tire TCO.

Comparing Tire Options

To understand the potential savings, we'll compare two tire configurations while keeping the trailer tires the same in both scenarios.

Screen of current tire selection for fuel savings calculator

Current tire selection

Fuel-savings calculator screen showing current tire selections for the example provided.

proposed tires on fuel-savings calculator

Proposed tires for cost savings

Fuel-savings calculator screen showing proposed tire selections for the example provided.

The Calculation

The proposed tire configuration offers improvements in rolling resistance compared with the baseline tires:

  • Michelin X® Line Energy Z+: 12%(1) lower rolling resistance than the Michelin X® Line Energy Z.

  • Michelin X® Line Energy D+: 22%(2) lower rolling resistance than the Michelin XDN2.

To account for differences in tire costs and performance, the calculation also assumes a $25 higher purchase price per tire and 50,000 fewer miles of tread life for the Michelin X® Line Energy D+ compared with the XDN2.

The original calculation also incorporates a 12% mileage improvement for the Michelin X® Line Energy Z+ compared with its predecessor, based on innovations developed through Michelin's SuperTruck 2 project.(3)

Even with the higher initial tire purchase price, the calculator estimates the proposed configuration could deliver approximately 1,144 gallons in annual fuel savings per truck, along with lower annualized tire costs.

The Bottom Line: Potential Annual Fleet Savings

The results show that lower rolling resistance can deliver fuel savings while differences in tire life and replacement costs can also affect overall tire expenses.

Although the proposed tires have a higher initial purchase price, this scenario demonstrates how evaluating total cost of ownership rather than purchase price alone can reveal opportunities to reduce fleet operating costs.

Actual savings will vary based on fuel prices, vehicle configuration, annual mileage, tire selection and operating conditions.

view of executive summary on fuel-savings calculator

Potential fuel and tire cost savings

Fuel-savings calculator screen showing the executive summary of potential fuel and tire savings each year based on the example provided.


Including Maintenance and Downtime in Your TCO Model

A complete tire total cost of ownership (TCO) analysis goes beyond purchase price and fuel consumption to include maintenance expenses and tire-related downtime. While tire purchase and fuel costs are relatively straightforward to calculate, maintenance costs can be more difficult to quantify.

To account for maintenance, fleets can start with a standard cost for tire changes and factor in how frequently tires need to be replaced. This may include labor, tire service expenses and other maintenance costs associated with keeping trucks on the road. These expenses can then be calculated annually or on a cost-per-mile basis.

Tire-related breakdowns are another important consideration. Unexpected downtime can lead to emergency roadside service expenses, delivery delays and lost productivity. Including these potential costs provides a more complete picture of how tire performance affects fleet operations.
 

Breaking Down Budget Silos

One of the challenges fleets face when adopting a total cost of ownership (TCO) approach is managing separate budgets for tires, fuel and vehicle maintenance. Each department may have its own performance goals and key performance indicators (KPIs), making it difficult to evaluate costs across the entire operation.

For example, investing in tires with lower rolling resistance may increase the tire purchasing budget while helping reduce fuel expenses. However, when departments are evaluated independently, the team responsible for tire purchasing may not receive credit for savings achieved elsewhere in the organization.

By evaluating tire, fuel and maintenance expenses together, fleet managers can make purchasing decisions based on overall operating costs rather than individual departmental budgets. This approach helps identify opportunities where a higher initial investment could lead to greater long-term savings.

As fleets develop their TCO models, aligning departmental goals and performance measurements can help ensure that fuel savings, tire performance and maintenance costs are considered together.

Fleets can also explore retread options to extend tire value and potentially reduce tire costs over time.
 

How Fuel-Efficient Tires Can Help Reduce CO₂ Emissions

Reducing tire rolling resistance can benefit both a fleet's operating costs and its environmental performance. Tires with lower rolling resistance require less energy to move a vehicle, which can help reduce fuel consumption and the associated carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions.

For diesel-powered fleets, using less fuel means producing less CO₂ during vehicle operation. Over thousands of miles and across multiple vehicles, even modest improvements in fuel efficiency can contribute to a fleet's broader sustainability goals.

By considering rolling resistance as part of a tire total cost of ownership (TCO) strategy, fleet managers can identify opportunities to reduce fuel expenses while also lowering fuel-related CO₂ emissions.
 

Commercial truck tire on a highway surrounded by mountains and forest

Michelin Million Mile Casing

Get More Value From Your Tires With Michelin Million Mile Casing

Lower rolling resistance is only one part of tire TCO. Michelin's Million Mile Casing technology is designed to support multiple tire lifecycles through retreading, helping fleets maximize tire value and manage long-term operating costs.

You are using and outdated Web Browser.

You are using a browser that is not supported by this website. This means that some functionality may not work as intended. This may result in strange behaviors when browsing round.

Use or upgrade/install one of the following browsers to take full advantage of this website

Firefox 78+
Edge 18+
Chrome 72+
Safari 12+
Opera 71+